Parents blamed over Gang Culture
Interesting isn't it. Whenever something goes right, everyone takes the credit. Whenever something goes wrong, discredit and culpability is localised (or 'microcosmicised').
“Det Supt Matthew Horne said some were only 13 when the crimes took place.
"To their parents I would ask them this: what were your kids doing? Where did you think they were..?" he said.”
All it takes for many to start cheering when England scores a goal in the World Cup, or some bloke sprints past all others in a 100 metres scamper in the Olympics, is for an association to be made, however tenuous, between themselves and the ball-kicker or scamperer. Well, how about the case of the 'sword death gang' then?
To err on the side of caution and consider collective collusion in the above, amongst others, is to acknowledge the infallibility of human society and ready ourselves to do our utmost to undermine the foundation upon which such events see repetition in the future. To ‘localise’ problems and delegate responsibility to, for instance, ‘families’, can only be at the expense of ignoring the symbiotic nature of human society; the sociological consequences of life within a class-based system; and the myriad of psychological consequences that immediately move from the ‘possible’ to the ‘probable’ within such a scheme of things. I can understand when a significant mass of Americans and American-led peoples do that since they are trained to do so from childhood by sociologically nonsensical American productions that basically localises ‘evil’ in the ‘here and now’, or in individual characters, and thereby subtly compromising the viewer’s ability over time to recognise causes as effects of other causes. But to see such a tendency here amongst a people who are generally inclined to stave off their first reactions in favour of self-critical evaluation is quite disconcerting.
But, as is generally the case here, Justice Keith appreciated the culpability of the collective in the evils in society by recognising the relevance of professions well-versed in the art of detecting social culpability in such situations,
“Addressing Paul's attackers, he said: "So what turned you into the would-be killers that you became didn't start at home.
"There is self-evidently a culture among boys of your age to do with the carrying of knives which needs to be changed.
"How that change is to be achieved is for educationalists, sociologists and politicians to decide.”
ed
Comments
It's interesting that we see the parental actions coming into account- perhaps a little more productive than telling the masses that they shouldn't let their kids listen to Marylin Manson. Having said that blaming the parents is a bit of a minefield in it's own right- but closer towards a thoughtful rationalisation than a response such as: "Kids play GTA4 therefore we have a culture of violence".
Maybe one day we will get there....